What’s So Wrong With Compromise?

One of the most disturbing aspects of the ongoing budget and debt battles in Congress and throughout the country is the refusal of some legislators and the Tea Partiers to accept the importance of bargaining and compromise as critical to the survival of our nation.

The United States and its governing system was founded on the working principles of trying to bring various groups, regions and allegiances together by finding commmon ground and then using the skills of bargaining and compromise as a way of resolving disputes.

What we have now in Washsington is a rejection of that tradition as political leaders state openly that compromise is a sign of weakness and a complete victory over one’s adversaries is the only true policy path.

This thinking creates an ugly atmosphere as legislators refuse to find a consensus and show little respect for bipartisan cooperation. What occurs instead are shouting matches on the floor of Congress, a reluctance to even talk to those from the other side of the aisle, and a commitment to an ideological position no matter whether that position is proven wrong or may lead to a dead end.

It is interesting in a troublesome way how little the Tea Party and its legislative representatives know about the Constitution, even though they claim that they are the major protectors of this document.

The Constitution above all else was based on pragmatism and realism. The Founding Fathers knew that in order to make a nation out of 13 colonies there had to be give and take and the understanding that taking a hard and fast position would lead nowhere but to gridlock and inaction.

That is why the Constitution takes a balanced view on the relationship between the federal government and the states; that is why the Constitution writers created the concept of checks and balances among the three branches of government; and that is why the Constitution developed a complex and undemocratic electoral system that satisfied the propertied elites by keeping slaves, women, native Americans and even men who had no land out of the voting process.

Compromise was at the heart of the Constitution and those in Congress who see compromise as a dirty word ought to read up on how this nation was founded and how it prospered as a result of a simple commitment to compromise.

2 Responses to What’s So Wrong With Compromise?

  1. mcoville says:

    “the refusal of some legislators and the Tea Partiers to accept the importance of bargaining and compromise as critical to the survival of our nation.” You forgot to mention the progressives and Democrats that refuse to negotiate. The DNC and progressives have done nothing to open up negotiations, all they have done is fan the fires of rhetoric and fear mongering.

    I agree that both sides have drawn lines in the sand and are holding their line against the “enemy”.

    My only concern is that when the GOP talks responsible spending and a balanced budget the DNC does nothing but cry murder. I would love to see a balanced budget plan from the Democrats, but I am not holding my breath until that happens. Then again, the GOP has not present a completely balanced budget yet either, but then again if they did the Dems would scream that the Republicans want to kill every age, ethnic or age group that they could think of.

    You can not negotiate with an unwilling partner.

  2. Matt says:

    It’s really rich to hear about democrats not compromising. Having just paid thru the nose (78million below Obama’s budget) to eliminate non-budgetary riders (attacking planned parenthood?), its the democrats that aren’t compromising?

    And as for an unwilling partner… which party was advocating FOR the shutdown? which party’s leaders went before crowds to encourage chants of “shut it down”?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: